Carlo's Pizza Shirley Menu (Update 2025)
Introducing the menu at Carlo's Pizza Shirley, located at 451 Glen Dr, Shirley, NY, is a culinary delight for pizza lovers. Their offerings prominently feature a range of mouthwatering appetizers, like the Fried Calamari and Stuffed Mushrooms, which set the stage for the main event: their renowned pizzas.
The signature deep-dish pizza boasts a crispy, airy crust and a flavorful sauce, earning rave reviews from patrons. Beyond pizza, the menu includes delicious hot heroes and paninis, with favorites like the Eggplant Parmigiana and a savory Chicken Panini.
Whether indulging in classic flavors or enjoying unique specialties, Carlo's Pizza Shirley promises a satisfying dining experience complemented by warm service. For those seeking comfort food combined with quality, this is a must-visit destination!
Hot Heros
Broccoli Rabe Parmigiana
with Chicken or Sausage
Shrimp Parmigiana
Shrimp breaded, topped with mozzarella cheese with our original tomato sauce.
Eggplant Parmigiana
Breaded Eggplant with Tomato Sauce and Covered in Mozzarella Cheese.
Blackened Chicken Panini
Side of Tomato, Vodka or Alfredo Sauce
Chicken with Roasted Red Pepper Panini
Side of Tomato, Vodka or Alfredo Sauce
Chicken, Lettuce and Tomato Panini
Side of Tomato, Vodka or Alfredo Sauce
Eggplant with Roasted Red Pepper Panini
Side of Tomato, Vodka or Alfredo Sauce
Paninis
Appetizers
Rice Ball
Filled with Meat, Peas, Onions and Cheese.
Baked Clams
Seasoned with Bread Crumbs, Garlic & Olive Oil.
Wings
Choose Your Size and Sauce.
Mozzarella Sticks
Served with marinara sauce.
Chicken Fingers (12)
Comes with a Side of Honey Mustard.
Hot Antipasto
Stuffed Mushrooms, Baked Clams, Fried Calamari and Eggplant Rollatini.
Clams Casino
Seasoned with Bell Peppers, Bacon, Garlic & Bread Crumbs
Fried Calamari
Battered & Deep Fried, Served with Marinara Sauce
Zucchini Sticks
Fresh Zucchini Sliced, Breaded & Fried to a Golden Brown & Served with Marinara Sauce.
Stuffed Mushrooms
Seasoned and Stuffed with Crab Meat Topped with Mozzarella Cheese
Mussels Marinara
Sauteed in Garlic then Simmered in our Original Tomato Sauce
Bianco
Mussels served in your choice of sauce over pasta.
Broccoli Rabe
Sauteed with Sweet Italian Sausage in Garlic & Oil
Baked Ziti Balls (4)
Breaded and Fried Baked Ziti Covered in Vodka Sauce
Meatballs (2)
Served with our Original Tomato Sauce.
Tossed Salad (Small)
Lettuce, Tomato, Onions, Cucumbers, and Olives.
Tossed Garden Salad
Lettuce, Tomato, Onions, Cucumbers, and Olives.
Antipasto Salad (Boars Head)
Ham, Salami, Provolone, Lettuce, Tomatoes, Carrots Cauliflower, Peppers, and Olives.
Scungill Salad
Tender Scungilli on a Bed of Lettuce Decorated with Celery, Olives and Tomatoes Served Cold.
Caesar Salad (Small)
Romaine Lettuce Grated Romano Cheese and Cherry Tomatoes.
Caesar Salad
Romaine Lettuce Grated Romano Cheese and Cherry Tomatoes.
Calamari Salad
Romaine Lettuce, Grated Romano Cheese, Cherry Tomatoes.
Greek Salad (Small)
Lettuce, Tomato, Onions, Olives, Carrots, Cucumbers, Red Cabbage and Fresh Feta Cheese.
Greek Salad
Lettuce, Tomato, Onions, Olives, Carrots, Cucumbers, Red Cabbage and Fresh Feta Cheese.
Fresh Mozzarella Tomato & Basil
In Olive Oil.
Chicken Bacon Cheddar Salad
Lettuce, Tomato, Bacon, Onion, Cheddar, Cucumber & Crispy Chicken.
Italian Chef Salad
Romaine Lettuce, Salami, Provolone, Pepperoni, Roasted Peppers, Olives & Capers.
Soups & Salads
Pizza
Sicilian (12 Slices)
12 slices.
Deep Dish
Round Sicilian. No Toppings.
Stuffed Pizza (Large)
Meat or Veg
Specialty Pies
Pasta Dishes
Penne Alfredo with Chicken
Pasta in a Creamy Alfredo Sauce with Sauteed Chicken Breast, Fresh Tomato and Peas.
Pasta with Sausage
Linguini Pasta, Topped with our Original Tomato Sauce.
Fettuccine Alfredo
Fettuccine Pasta in a Creamy Alfredo Sauce.
Pasta with Meatballs
Linguini Pasta, Topped with our Original Tomato Sauce.
Spaghetti with Marinara
Topped with our Original Tomato Sauce.
Penne ala Vodka
Penne Pasta in a Pink Creamy Vodka Sauce with Red Onions and Ham.
Stuffed Shells Parmigiana (Home-Made)
Homemade.
Ravioli Parmigiana
Stuffed with Cheese.
Lobster Ravioli
Choice of Alfredo, Vodka or Marinara Parmigiana.
Tortellini with Marinara Sauce
Topped with our Original Tomato Sauce.
Tortellini with Alfredo Sauce
Topped with our Original White Cream Sauce.
Rigatoni with Meat Sauce
Topped with our Original Tomato Sauce with Chunks of Ground Beef.
Spaghetti with Broccoli
Sauteed with Garlic and Oil.
Shrimp Marinara
Shrimp Sauteed in our Original Tomato Sauce.
Shrimp Farfale
Shrimp with Garlic, Broccoli Rabe & Sun-Dried Tomatoes and Sauteed in Olive Oil & White Wine, Served over Bow-Tie Pasta.
Shrimp Oreganata
Shrimp Topped with Seasoned Bread Crumbs in a Light Sauce of Butter, Garlic & White Wine.
Shrimp Scampi
Shrimp in Garlic, Butter & Wine Sauce.
Shrimp Alfredo
Shrimp Sauteed in a Creamy Alfredo Sauce.
Shrimp Piccata
Shrimp Sauteed with Artichoke Hearts with White Wine Lemon and Butter.
Shrimp with Garlic & Oil
Shrimp Sauteed and Seasoned in Garlic & Oil Sauce.
Shrimp Fra Diavolo
Shrimp in a Spicy Marinara Sauce.
Shrimp in Pesto
Shrimp Sauteed in a Creamy Pesto Sauce.
Shrimp
Veal
Veal Sorrentino
Veal Sauteed in White Wine Topped with Prosciutto, Sliced Tomato and Mozzarella.
Veal Marsala
Veal Sauteed with Mushrooms in a Marsala Wine Sauce and Prosciutto.
Veal Rollatini
Veal Cutlet Rolled with Cheese, Ham, Seasonings Cooked in a Delicate Wine Sauce and Mushrooms.
Veal Parmigiana
Veal Sauteed with & Covered with Mozzarella Topped with our Original Tomato Sauce.
Veal Piccata
Veal Delicately Sauteed with White Wine, Lemon & Artichoke Hearts.
Veal Cacciatore
Veal Cooked with Onions, Mushrooms and Pepper Sauteed with Plum Tomatoes and a Splash of Wine.
Veal Francaise
Veal Dipped in Egg-Batter and Sauteed in a Wine and Lemon Sauce.
Chicken Marsala
Chicken Sauteed with Mushrooms in a Marsala wine Sauce and Prosciutto.
Chicken Francese
Chicken Breast Dipped in Egg Batter and Sauteed in a Wine and Lemon Sauce.
Chicken Piccata
Chicken Breast Delicately Sauteed with White Wine, Lemon & Artichoke Hearts.
Chicken Scaprella
Chicken Breast and Sweet Italian Sausage Delicately Sauteed with a Lemon & Garlic & Wine Sauce.
Chicken Sorrentino
Chicken Sauteed in White Wine Topped with Prosciutto, Sliced Tomato and Mozzarella.
Chicken Mediterranean
Chicken, Eggplant, Diced Tomatoes & Zucchini Sauteed in Chunk Tomato and Wine Sauce, Topped with Mozzarella.
Chicken Parmigiana
Chicken Delicately Sauteed and Covered with Mozzarella, Topped with our Original Tomato Sauce.
Chicken Rollatini
Breast of Chicken Rolled with Cheese, Ham & Assorted Seasonings, Cooked in a Delicate Wine Sauce and Mushrooms.
Chicken Cacciatore
Chicken Breast Cooked with Onions, and Peppers, Sauteed in a Plum Tomato Sauce and a Splash of Wine.
Chicken
Seafood
Calamari
Fresh Squid Sauteed in our Marinara Sauce and Served Over Pasta.
Scungilli Marinara
Fresh Squid or Conch Sauteed in our Marinara Sauce, Served Over Pasta.
Seafood Scampi Combo
Shrimp, and Lobster Tail, Sauteed in Butter, Garlic & White Wine.
Seafood Terrano
Lobster Tail & Shrimp Sauteed in a Marinara Sauce Over Pasta.
Pescatore
Shrimp, Calamari, Clams & Mussels in a Light Marinara Sauce Served Over Pasta.
Zuppa de Pesce
Shrimp, Scungilli, Calamari, Clams, Mussels & Lobster Cooked Together in a Spicy, Light Marinara Sauce, Served Over Pasta.
Seafood Fra Diavolo Alla Carlo
Shrimp in a Spicy Marinara Sauce Served with Mussels & Clams Over Pasta.
Seafood Ala Vodka
Shrimp and Scallops Sauteed with Spinach in a Cream Vodka Sauce.
Spaghetti & Marinara Sauce
Topped with our Original Tomato Sauce.
Children's Menu
Rolls & Calzones
Calzone
with our Original Tomato Sauce.
Stuffed Garlic Knots
Fresh Mozzarella, Tomato and Prosciutto
Calzone with Ham
w/ham & sauce.
Regular Slice
W/ chicken.
Slices
Beverages
Pepsi (20 oz)
The bold, refreshing, robust cola
Diet Coke (20 oz)
A crisp, refreshing taste you know and love with zero calories.
Starry (20 oz)
The cold, refreshing flavors of lemon and lime, perfectly blended.
Pepsi (2 Liter)
The bold, refreshing, robust cola
Diet Coke (2 Liter)
A crisp, refreshing taste you know and love with zero calories.
Homemade Cherry cheesecake
Rich, creamy cheesecake topped with cherry
Homemade Blueberry Cheesecake
Rich, creamy cheesecake topped with blueberry.
Homemade Strawberry cheesecake
Creamy cheesecake topped with strawberry
Homemade Oreo Cheesecake
Rich creamy Oreo cheesecake topped with chocolate